Want to Be Like San Diego, Mayor Singh-Allen? Start by Dumping Flock
Across America, opposition to Flock and other automated license plate readers has become an increasingly bipartisan movement
The San Diego City Council voted Monday to shut down the city's controversial Flock automated license plate readers and smart streetlight surveillance cameras, delivering a significant victory to privacy advocates and residents concerned about government surveillance.
The council voted 7-0 to withdraw authorization for automated license plate readers and 5-2 to end authorization for smart streetlight cameras.
The decision followed mounting criticism of the technology, including reports that San Diego police used license plate readers to track a domestic violence victim and a police officer during an internal investigation.
The controversy prompted several council members to reconsider their support. Even Mayor Todd Gloria, previously a defender of the technology, announced he would not veto the council's decision.
Gloria acknowledged that the technology had lost public trust, despite safeguards intended to prevent misuse.
San Diego Police Chief Scott Wahl opposed eliminating the cameras, arguing that the technology had assisted investigations in more than 900 cases.
But the council ultimately concluded that the privacy concerns and erosion of public trust outweighed those arguments.
And San Diego is hardly alone.
Across America, opposition to Flock and other automated license plate readers has become an increasingly bipartisan movement, uniting progressive civil liberties advocates with conservatives suspicious of government surveillance.
Communities including Syracuse, New York; Mountain View, California; Salem, Massachusetts; and South Kingstown, Rhode Island, have removed cameras, discontinued their use or canceled Flock contracts.
In Centerton, Arkansas, a Republican council member who originally supported installing Flock cameras helped lead a unanimous vote to cancel the city's contract after residents raised privacy concerns.
Apparently, protecting citizens from government overreach is one of those rare issues where Republicans and Democrats can occasionally agree.
Which brings us to Elk Grove Mayor Bobbie Singh-Allen.
For years, Singh-Allen has envisioned transforming Elk Grove's beleaguered historic Old Town into a bustling tourist destination comparable to San Diego's famous Gaslamp Quarter.
The mayor has repeatedly invoked the Gaslamp Quarter as a model for what Old Town might someday become.
Well, Mayor, here's a golden opportunity to make Elk Grove more like San Diego without spending millions on consultants, redevelopment schemes or another grand vision.
Follow San Diego's example and listen to residents concerned about government surveillance.
Elk Grove residents have repeatedly raised concerns about Flock cameras, including questions about access to license plate data by outside law enforcement agencies.
Yet Singh-Allen has resisted calls to remove the cameras, even as other communities reconsider the wisdom of collecting and sharing the movements of ordinary motorists.
San Diego's elected officials eventually recognized that public trust matters more than the convenience of electronic surveillance.
Elk Grove's elected officials could reach the same conclusion.
After all, if abandoning Flock is good enough for California's second-largest city, surely it's good enough for Elk Grove.
Mayor Singh-Allen doesn't need a Gaslamp Quarter to make Elk Grove more like San Diego.
She just needs to turn off the damn cameras.