Former Elk Grove Planning Commissioner reminds mayor, city council of rural area commitments

During the Wednesday, June 11, Elk Grove City Council meeting, the city's longest-serving planning commissioner spoke about the city's long-standing commitments to its rural areas.

Speaking during public comment on non-agenda items was George Murphey, who ended his 17-year tenure on the planning commission in 2024. Murphey's remarks were made in the context of the proposed Summer Villas housing project on Sheldon and Waterman roads.

Mr. Murphey reminded the mayor and city council members of the city's long-standing commitment to preserving the area's large lots, which typify the area's character. Almost all parcels in the rural area are measured in acres, not square feet. 

The proposed Summer Villas project aims to develop a senior-only subdivision, which many in the rural area fear will lead to the proliferation of high-density subdivisions that dominate Elk Grove's housing landscape. Murphey's called the subdivision "the proverbial camel's nose."

Rural area residents are organizing an effort to convince Mayor Bobbie Singh-Allen and the city council to deny the project. Murphey expressed hope that non-rural residents will support their stance (see entire commentary in video below). 

Although none of the city council members have formally staked a position on the proposed development, speaking in general terms, Councilmember Kevin Spease, who grew up in the city's rural area, has expressed support for preserving the rural area in its current state. Conversely, Councilmember Darren Suen has appeared open to loosening standards to allow for higher density in the area. 

The rural area lies in District 2, which Councilmember Rod Brewer represents. Brewer has not indicated his stance on the project but in 2022, Brewer accepted $3,000 in campaign donations (page 9) from Summer Villas project proponents, Bryan Wilson and Gyan Kalwani's entity River City Waste Recyclers.